Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 Vs Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

If you’re standing in the tire aisle or browsing online, puzzled by the plethora of high-performance tire options, you’re not alone. Choosing between the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 and the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S can be daunting—both are acclaimed, but for potentially different reasons and driving conditions. This guide aims to simplify your decision, ensuring you drive away with tires that not just fit, but enhance, your driving experience.

The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S excels with superior wet and dry traction and is ideal for driving enthusiasts seeking ultimate performance, while the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 offers commendable longevity and value, particularly suited for regular drivers looking for a balance of performance and cost.

In this article, we provide an in-depth comparison of the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 and Michelin Pilot Sport 4S, analyzing their performance in wet and dry conditions, comfort, noise level, and treadwear to help you make an informed choice based on your driving needs.

Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

The Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 is a popular choice among driving enthusiasts looking for a high-performance summer tire that balances price with capability. Designed for passenger cars, this tire strives to offer a solid performance in both wet and dry conditions while ensuring driver comfort. Here’s a breakdown of its key performance metrics and some insights into its pros and cons.

Wet Performance

• Hydroplaning Resistance: 8.3/10
  The tire demonstrates a commendable ability to resist hydroplaning. Its grooves efficiently channel water away, reducing the risk of losing control on wet roads.
• Wet Traction: 7.9/10
  While it provides adequate traction in wet conditions, it doesn’t lead the pack. The tire performs well but falls short of the gripping capability showcased by some of its top-tier competitors.

Dry Performance

• Corner Stability: 8.6/10
  It offers reliable stability during cornering maneuvers. Whether you’re navigating a tight bend or a fast curve, the Asymmetric 3 holds its own, providing confidence to the driver.
• Dry Traction: 8.8/10
  The tire shines when the roads are dry, offering robust traction that ensures your car stays glued to the tarmac.
• Steering Response: 8.5/10
  Steering is precise and responsive, albeit not the most sharp compared to higher-rated peers. It reacts well to driver inputs, making it a trustworthy option for everyday driving.

Comfort

• Ride Quality: 8.6/10
  Drivers can expect a smooth ride that competently absorbs bumps and imperfections in the road surface.
• Noise: 8.4/10
  Road noise is adequately subdued, allowing for a quieter cabin experience at high speeds and during long drives.

Treadwear

• Overall Treadwear Performance: 8.5/10
  The Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 wears evenly and slowly, promising a longer lifespan. However, it lacks a warranty on tread life, which may be a concern for high-mileage drivers.

Pros

• Balanced Performance: Delivers solid dry and wet traction, making it a versatile choice for various driving conditions.
• Comfort: Offers a smooth and quiet ride, enhancing the overall driving experience.
• Treadwear: Exhibits commendable durability, providing good value over its lifespan.

Cons

• Wet Traction: Does not excel in wet conditions as some of its competitors, which could be a drawback for drivers in rainier climates.
• No Treadwear Warranty: The absence of a treadwear warranty might deter some potential buyers, especially those who drive frequently and cover substantial mileage annually.

Overall Summary

The Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 is a well-rounded high-performance summer tire that offers a good mix of dry and wet performance, comfort, and durability. It’s suited for drivers who need a reliable tire that performs well in a variety of conditions but might not be the best fit for those who prioritize top-tier wet performance or require a treadwear warranty. This tire stands as a compelling option for the cost-conscious enthusiast who doesn’t want to compromise too much on quality or performance.

Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is renowned for its exceptional performance among high-performance summer tires, making it a favored choice for car enthusiasts and everyday drivers alike. Engineered for sports cars, high-powered sedans, and performance vehicles, this tire is designed to deliver top-tier traction and stability in both wet and dry conditions. Below, we examine its key performance metrics and discuss its strengths and potential drawbacks.

Wet Performance

• Hydroplaning Resistance: 8.8/10
  The Pilot Sport 4S boasts excellent hydroplaning resistance, thanks to its innovative tread design that effectively disperses water, enhancing safety during heavy rain.
• Wet Traction: 8.9/10
  It excels in wet conditions, providing a firm grip and reliable handling on slick surfaces, which markedly boosts driver confidence under adverse weather conditions.

Dry Performance

• Corner Stability: 9.5/10
  This tire stands out with its superior cornering ability. The precise construction allows for remarkable stability and control, even at high speeds and tight corners.
• Dry Traction: 9.6/10
  Among the best in its class, the dry traction offered by the Pilot Sport 4S is nearly unmatched, ensuring exceptional handling and performance on dry roads.
• Steering Response: 9.5/10
  The tire responds to steering inputs with pinpoint accuracy, giving the driver a tactile and immediate feel for the road, enhancing the driving experience significantly.

Comfort

• Ride Quality: 8.9/10
  Michelin has not compromised on comfort, with the Pilot Sport 4S providing a ride that is both plush and stable, a rare find in high-performance tires.
• Noise: 8.6/10
  The tire operates quietly, minimizing road noise, which contributes to a more enjoyable and less intrusive journey, even at highway speeds.

Treadwear

• Overall Treadwear Performance: 8.1/10
  With a focus on longevity as well as performance, the Pilot Sport 4S offers durable tread life and comes with a warranty of 30,000 miles, appealing to those who put their cars through regular paces.

Pros

• Exceptional Wet and Dry Performance: Sets a high benchmark in both categories, making it an ideal all-rounder for various driving conditions.
• High Comfort Levels: Despite its aggressive performance attributes, it does not sacrifice comfort, ensuring a pleasant ride.
• Robust Treadwear Warranty: Comes with a 30,000-mile warranty, providing peace of mind and added value over its lifespan.

Cons

• Premium Price Tag: The high level of performance comes at a cost, making it one of the more expensive options in the high-performance tire segment.

Overall Summary

The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is a powerhouse in the realm of high-performance summer tires. It is tailored for drivers who demand the utmost from their vehicles, whether navigating sharp bends on a backroad or cruising on a rain-soaked highway. The combination of stellar performance in wet and dry conditions, comfort, and a solid warranty makes it a compelling choice, albeit at a higher price point. It is particularly well-suited for those willing to invest in top-quality tires that deliver safety, durability, and performance.

Comparative Analysis

When deciding between the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 and the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S, it’s essential to understand how each performs under various conditions. This section provides a head-to-head comparison to highlight the differences and assist you in determining the right choice for your driving needs.

Performance in Wet Conditions

• Hydroplaning Resistance:
  • Goodyear: 8.3/10
  • Michelin: 8.8/10
  The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S provides superior resistance to hydroplaning compared to the Goodyear, thanks to its advanced tread design that excels at channeling water away effectively.
• Wet Traction:
  • Goodyear: 7.9/10
  • Michelin: 8.9/10
  In wet traction, the Michelin outperforms the Goodyear significantly. This makes the Pilot Sport 4S a more reliable option in rainy conditions, offering better grip and control.

Performance in Dry Conditions

• Corner Stability:
  • Goodyear: 8.6/10
  • Michelin: 9.5/10
  The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S again takes the lead with exceptional corner stability that enhances driver confidence during aggressive driving and in sharp turns.
• Dry Traction:
  • Goodyear: 8.8/10
  • Michelin: 9.6/10
  For dry traction, the Michelin offers unparalleled performance, ensuring maximum contact with the road for superior grip.
• Steering Response:
  • Goodyear: 8.5/10
  • Michelin: 9.5/10
  With a more responsive steering feel, the Michelin provides a tactile driving experience, allowing for precise maneuvers and better control.

Comfort and Noise

• Ride Quality:
  • Goodyear: 8.6/10
  • Michelin: 8.9/10
  Both tires offer high levels of comfort, but the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S edges out slightly, providing a smoother ride even on rough surfaces.
• Noise Level:
  • Goodyear: 8.4/10
  • Michelin: 8.6/10
  Michelin also leads in noise reduction, making for a quieter and more enjoyable driving experience, particularly at high speeds.

Treadwear and Longevity

• Treadwear Rating:
  • Goodyear: 8.5/10
  • Michelin: 8.1/10
  The Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 shows a slight advantage in treadwear, suggesting that it might last longer under similar conditions, despite lacking a mileage warranty.
• Warranty Mileage:
  • Goodyear: None
  • Michelin: 30,000 Miles
  Although Goodyear might have a better treadwear rating, Michelin backs its Pilot Sport 4S with a 30,000-mile warranty, offering reassurance on the tire’s longevity and quality.

Choosing Between the Two

• Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3: A solid option for those who value a good balance of wet and dry performance with a potential edge in longevity. It’s well-suited for drivers who are cost-conscious but still want a tire that performs reliably across most conditions.
• Michelin Pilot Sport 4S: The go-to choice for automotive enthusiasts who demand peak performance in both wet and dry conditions and are willing to pay a premium for advanced technology and comfort. Its warranty and superior handling characteristics provide additional peace of mind.

Other Competitors in the Market

While the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 and the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S are standout choices in the high-performance summer tire category, several other tires are worth considering. Each of these alternatives brings its unique strengths to the table, catering to different preferences and driving conditions. Let’s take a closer look at some notable competitors.

Continental ExtremeContact Sport 02

Bridgestone Potenza Sport

Yokohama ADVAN Apex V601

Choosing Among Competitors

When evaluating these alternatives, consider the following factors to align with your specific needs:

• Wet and Dry Performance: If you live in a region with frequent rain, prioritize tires with high wet performance ratings. For mostly dry conditions, focus on dry traction and stability.
• Comfort and Noise: Daily drivers should look for tires that offer a comfortable ride and low noise levels to enhance the driving experience.
• Treadwear and Warranty: Consider how much you drive annually. Tires with higher treadwear ratings and warranties offer better long-term value.

Resources

Below are some links you may find helpful when learning about tires:

• Goodyear Product Page
• Michelin Product Page
• Max performance summer consumer ratings – Tire Rack

Final Thoughts

This article has detailed the strengths and weaknesses of the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 and Michelin Pilot Sport 4S. If your priority is top-tier performance in both wet and dry conditions with the assurance of durability and comfort, the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is your best bet.

However, if you are more concerned with cost-effectiveness and still require a tire that performs robustly across most standard driving conditions, the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 offers a valuable proposition. Consider what you value most in your vehicle’s tires—whether it’s the thrill of the drive itself or the practicality of tire longevity and cost.

Good luck and happy motoring.