5 Best All Terrain Tires For The Money

Imagine you’re preparing for your next off-road adventure or simply looking to upgrade your daily drive. Tires are your vehicle’s first line of defense against varying terrain conditions, and choosing the right set can be a game-changer. That’s why finding the best all-terrain tires for the money isn’t just a necessity—it’s a strategy to enhance safety, performance, and comfort.

The best all-terrain tires for the money, offering a balance of performance, durability, and cost-effectiveness, are:

1. Sumitomo Encounter AT
2. Firestone Destination AT2
3. Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT
4. Toyo Open Country AT III
5. Falken WildPeak AT3W

In this article, you’ll discover detailed reviews of each tire, insights into how they were ranked, and essential tips for selecting tires that offer the best value for your specific driving needs.

Sumitomo Encounter AT

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

---

The Sumitomo Encounter AT offers a unique balance between affordability and reliable performance, making it a standout choice for budget-conscious drivers with diverse driving needs. It is particularly suited for light trucks and SUVs and is designed to handle a variety of terrains from highways to trails, providing robust functionality without a premium price tag.

• Strengths: The Encounter AT excels in delivering consistent performance across various surfaces. Its engineered tread design affords excellent grip on dirt and sand, and substantial rock traction, which is crucial for off-road driving. Wet conditions are where this tire truly shines; its deep grooves and specialized tread patterns enhance hydroplaning resistance, offering a stable and secure drive during heavy rains. In dry conditions, it provides strong traction and responsive handling, enabling precise cornering and effective braking.
• Weaknesses and Limitations: Though the Sumitomo Encounter AT is adept in many conditions, it exhibits limitations in heavy snow and icy environments, typical of all-terrain tires, which are not specifically winter-focused. In comparison to some specialized competitors, such as the Falken WildPeak AT3W, it may offer slightly inferior rock-crawling capabilities, which could be a drawback for hardcore off-road enthusiasts.
• Value Proposition: Where this tire sets itself apart is in its value for money. Priced significantly lower than many competitors while still offering comparable, if not superior, performance metrics in key areas (such as wet and dry traction), the Encounter AT represents a smart purchase for those who need effective all-season capability but wish to avoid the steep costs associated with top-tier brands.
• Comfort and Durability: The Encounter AT does not compromise on comfort; it effectively reduces road noise, which is a significant benefit for both daily drivers and long-distance travelers. Durability is another hallmark of this tire, with a wear-resistant compound that promotes even tread wear and prolongs lifespan, maximizing the return on investment.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Excels in hydroplaning resistance and wet traction, outperforming peers like the Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT, and providing confidence in rainy conditions.
• Dry Performance: While it provides good stability and traction, it slightly trails the Toyo Open Country AT III in maximum grip and agility.
• Winter Performance: Handles light and moderate snow well, similar to the Firestone Destination AT2, but falls short in handling severe winter conditions, necessitating supplemental winter tires.
• Comfort and Noise: Offers a quieter and smoother ride compared to many in its class, including the Falken WildPeak AT3W.
• Treadwear: Durable construction ensures it lasts longer than many competitors, such as the Goodyear Wrangler TrailRunner AT, which may show quicker signs of wear under similar conditions.

PROS

• Excellent performance in wet conditions with superior hydroplaning resistance.
• High cost-effectiveness, offering significant savings without compromising on essential capabilities.
• Quieter and more comfortable than many competitors, enhancing driver and passenger experience.
• Durable and long-lasting, providing great value over the tire’s lifespan.

CONS

• Limited capability in severe snow and ice, typical of all-terrain tires but notable if comparing with winter-specific options.
• Slightly less adept in extreme off-road conditions compared to the top-tier rugged tires.

BOTTOM LINE

For the economically minded driver who does not want to compromise on safety and performance, the Sumitomo Encounter AT is an exemplary choice. It offers a compelling mix of price and capability, making it one of the best all-terrain tires for the money on the market today. With strengths in handling diverse conditions—particularly in wet weather—and a reputation for durability, this tire is an intelligent investment for those who need reliable all-season performance without the premium price. Whether navigating daily commutes or venturing on occasional off-road excursions, the Encounter AT stands ready to deliver robust performance and exceptional value.

Firestone Destination AT2

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

---

The Firestone Destination AT2 is designed for drivers seeking rugged durability and all-terrain capability at a price point that doesn’t hit the wallet hard. This tire is well-suited for SUVs, light trucks, and off-road vehicles, offering a reliable performance across a variety of driving conditions without compromising on cost.

• Strengths: The Destination AT2 shines across numerous terrains with a special emphasis on traction and grip. Whether navigating loose gravel, slick mud, or uneven rock, the tire’s aggressive tread pattern and robust construction provide solid footing. Its performance in wet conditions is particularly impressive, thanks to its optimized tread design that channels water efficiently, enhancing hydroplaning resistance and wet traction. On dry roads, the tire maintains commendable stability and responsiveness, supporting safer and more controlled driving experiences.
• Weaknesses and Limitations: Like most all-terrain tires, the Destination AT2 struggles in severe winter conditions. It handles light to moderate snow with ease but lacks the specialized features necessary for optimal performance on ice and deep snow. Additionally, when compared to some higher-end competitors like the Toyo Open Country AT III, it may exhibit slightly reduced responsiveness in emergency maneuvers and high-speed cornering, which could be critical for more dynamic driving needs.
• Value Proposition: The Firestone Destination AT2 stands out for its excellent balance of performance and affordability. It is priced lower than many premium brands yet delivers a competitive edge in essential areas such as durability and all-season reliability. This makes it an attractive option for drivers looking to maximize their investment without sacrificing quality.
• Comfort and Durability: This tire also excels in driving comfort, significantly reducing road noise—a common complaint among all-terrain tires. The Destination AT2 is built to last, featuring a durable compound and a tread design that promotes even wear, thus extending the tire’s life and enhancing its overall value.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Rivals more expensive models with its superior hydroplaning resistance and excellent traction in wet conditions, surpassing the General Grabber ATX in this regard.
• Dry Performance: Offers solid traction and good handling on dry surfaces, though it may not match the Falken WildPeak AT3W in terms of dry grip and precision.
• Winter Performance: Comparable to the Sumitomo Encounter AT in its ability to handle light and moderate snow but falls short in harsh winter scenarios, similar to other all-terrain tires in its class.
• Comfort and Noise: Provides a quieter ride than many of its competitors, including the Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT, which is beneficial for both daily drives and longer trips.
• Treadwear: Demonstrates robust construction with longevity that rivals, and sometimes exceeds, that of pricier competitors like the Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus.

PROS

• Strong performance on various terrains, especially notable in wet conditions.
• Great value for money, offering premium features at a more accessible price point.
• Reduced road noise and enhanced comfort compared to many all-terrain tires.
• Durable build that promises extended tread life and consistent performance.

CONS

• Limited severe winter performance, requiring additional tires for optimal safety in snow and ice.
• Slightly less effective in high-speed maneuvers and precision cornering compared to top-tier models.

BOTTOM LINE

The Firestone Destination AT2 is a robust option for those seeking dependable all-terrain capabilities combined with economical pricing. It offers a practical compromise between advanced features and affordability, making it one of the best all-terrain tires for the money currently available. Its strengths in handling diverse weather conditions and its commitment to comfort and longevity make it a wise choice for drivers who expect high performance without a high cost. Whether it’s daily commuting or the occasional adventurous off-road trip, the Destination AT2 provides the reliability and value needed to confidently tackle a variety of driving challenges.

Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

---

The Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT is tailored for drivers who require a dependable all-terrain tire that performs well in a broad range of conditions and is priced within a moderate budget. Ideal for trucks, SUVs, and off-road vehicles, this tire offers solid performance without commanding the premium prices associated with some higher-end models.

• Strengths: The Workhorse AT excels in delivering reliable traction on various terrains including gravel, wet mud, and rocky surfaces. Its robust tread design and compound enhance grip significantly, providing a stable and secure ride. Wet performance is a key strength, with deep grooves and unique siping that prevent hydroplaning and maintain traction under heavy rain. In dry conditions, the tire offers good handling and braking responsiveness, ensuring a safe driving experience.
• Weaknesses and Limitations: While the Wrangler Workhorse AT is competent in handling light to moderate snow, its performance in heavy snow and icy conditions is less than ideal, mirroring the typical limitations of all-terrain tires in extreme winter scenarios. It also may not provide the same level of rock-crawling capability as the Falken WildPeak AT3W, potentially limiting its appeal to hardcore off-road enthusiasts.
• Value Proposition: The Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT is positioned as a high-value option within the all-terrain category. It offers many of the performance features of more expensive tires, such as the BFGoodrich TA KO2, but at a price point that is more accessible to a wider range of consumers. This makes it an excellent choice for those seeking a blend of performance and price efficiency.
• Comfort and Durability: Comfort is another significant advantage of the Workhorse AT, with design elements that minimize road noise more effectively than many competitors. The durability of the tire is commendable as well, featuring a tough construction that resists wear and tear through varied driving demands, thereby extending the tire’s usable life and enhancing overall value.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Outperforms many in its class with excellent hydroplaning resistance and wet traction, arguably matching the performance of the Sumitomo Encounter AT.
• Dry Performance: Provides reliable dry traction and handling, though it slightly lags behind the Toyo Open Country AT III in agility and speed responsiveness.
• Winter Performance: Handles light and moderate snow adequately but shares the common all-terrain tire limitation of reduced effectiveness in heavy snow and ice, similar to the Firestone Destination AT2.
• Comfort and Noise: Ranks above many alternatives like the General Grabber ATX in terms of reducing noise and improving ride comfort.
• Treadwear: Exhibits robust durability, potentially outlasting cheaper options like the Goodyear Wrangler TrailRunner AT, which tends to wear quicker under similar conditions.

PROS

• Strong wet and dry traction capabilities ensure safety and control.
• Exceptional value for the price, offering features often found in more expensive models.
• Quieter operation and increased comfort enhance the overall driving experience.
• Durable construction supports longevity and consistent performance over time.

CONS

• Limited capability in severe winter conditions necessitates additional winter tires for optimal safety.
• Not as adept at extreme off-roading compared to specialized models.

BOTTOM LINE

The Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT presents itself as a robust and economical choice in the all-terrain tire market. It provides a compelling mix of features that are designed to perform reliably in various driving conditions. While it may fall short in the harshest winter environments and the most challenging off-road situations, its strengths in everyday conditions, coupled with its competitive pricing, make it a strong contender for drivers looking for dependable performance without an exorbitant price tag. Whether used for daily commuting or occasional off-road adventures, the Workhorse AT offers a practical and cost-effective solution that does not compromise on quality or performance.

Toyo Open Country AT III

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

---

The Toyo Open Country AT III is engineered for drivers who demand robust performance across all terrains while managing their budget effectively. Suitable for SUVs, trucks, and adventurers who regularly transition from highway to trail, this tire offers superior capabilities without the premium price tag often found in this segment.

• Strengths: The Open Country AT III excels in providing exceptional traction on a variety of surfaces including mud, sand, and rock, thanks to its aggressive tread pattern and advanced rubber compound. It performs admirably in wet conditions with excellent hydroplaning resistance and enhanced grip, ensuring safety during rainy seasons. On dry roads, the tire’s stability and responsiveness are top-notch, allowing for precise handling and effective braking. Furthermore, it handles snow conditions better than many all-terrain tires, making it a viable option for drivers in colder climates.
• Weaknesses and Limitations: Despite its strengths, the Open Country AT III does have limitations. While it performs well in light to moderate snow, it is not equipped to handle severe ice and deep snow conditions as effectively as a dedicated winter tire. Additionally, in comparison to some top-tier competitors like the BFGoodrich TA KO2, it may offer slightly less durability in extremely rugged off-road conditions.
• Value Proposition: The Toyo Open Country AT III strikes an excellent balance between cost and performance. It is priced competitively, making it accessible for a wide range of budgets while still offering performance characteristics typically associated with more expensive models. This tire is a smart choice for those who need reliable all-season and all-terrain capabilities without overspending.
• Comfort and Durability: This tire is also designed with comfort in mind; it reduces road noise more effectively than many of its peers, which enhances the driving experience on both long journeys and daily commutes. The durability of the Open Country AT III is noteworthy, with a wear-resistant tread design that ensures long-term performance and reduces the frequency of tire replacements.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Excels in wet traction and hydroplaning resistance, comparable to the Sumitomo Encounter AT and better than the General Grabber ATX.
• Dry Performance: Offers excellent dry traction and handling, closely matching the performance of the Falken WildPeak AT3W and outperforming the Firestone Destination AT2 in agility.
• Winter Performance: More capable in snow than many all-terrain tires, including the Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT, but not suitable for severe winter conditions.
• Comfort and Noise: Provides a quieter and smoother ride than many competitors, such as the Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus.
• Treadwear: Durable construction and even wear characteristics position it well against more expensive alternatives like the BFGoodrich TA KO2, offering better value over time.

PROS

• Superior traction in both wet and dry conditions, ensuring comprehensive safety and control.
• Highly cost-effective, providing premium features without a premium price.
• Enhanced comfort with reduced road noise, improving the overall driving experience.
• Durable and designed for longevity, ideal for varied and continuous use.

CONS

• Limited performance in severe winter conditions, typical for all-terrain tires but notable for those in colder regions.
• Slightly less rugged durability for extreme off-roading compared to some specialized competitors.

BOTTOM LINE

The Toyo Open Country AT III is an outstanding choice for those seeking a high-performance all-terrain tire that balances price and capabilities. Its strengths in handling diverse weather and terrain conditions make it a top pick for drivers who prioritize versatility and dependability. While it may require additional winter tires for extreme conditions, its performance across other seasons and terrains ensures that it remains a competitive and appealing option in the all-terrain category. This tire is perfect for drivers who want to explore without limitations and without overspending, making it one of the best all-terrain tires for the money currently on the market.

Falken WildPeak AT3W

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

The Falken WildPeak AT3W is designed for enthusiasts who demand top-tier performance from their all-terrain tires, coupled with a competitive price point. This tire is ideal for SUVs, light trucks, and off-road vehicles that face challenging environments, offering robust capabilities across a wide range of conditions.

• Strengths: The WildPeak AT3W excels on various terrains, from muddy trails to snowy roads, with a special emphasis on rugged durability. Its aggressive tread pattern and deep grooves provide excellent traction in wet conditions, effectively preventing hydroplaning. On dry surfaces, the tire offers exceptional grip and responsiveness, allowing for precise steering and control, which enhances safety and driving confidence. It is also well-equipped for winter conditions, performing better in snow and ice than many standard all-terrain tires due to its severe snow rating.
• Weaknesses and Limitations: While the WildPeak AT3W is a formidable performer in most settings, it may exhibit slightly higher road noise compared to more road-focused all-terrain tires such as the Toyo Open Country AT III. Additionally, while it handles moderate to heavy snow well, it is not a substitute for specialized winter tires in extreme winter conditions.
• Value Proposition: The Falken WildPeak AT3W offers excellent value by combining high-end performance features with a reasonable price tag. It competes closely with more expensive models like the BFGoodrich TA KO2, delivering comparable or superior performance in many critical areas but at a lower cost. This makes it an appealing choice for drivers who need a reliable tire that won’t break the bank.
• Comfort and Durability: This tire is designed to provide a comfortable ride, although it may generate more noise on highways than some competitors. Durability is a strong point for the WildPeak AT3W; it features a rugged build that can withstand the abuses of off-road driving while maintaining even wear, which prolongs its service life and enhances its value.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Offers excellent hydroplaning resistance and wet traction, on par with the Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT and better than many in its price range.
• Dry Performance: Provides superior dry grip and handling, closely rivaling the performance of premium brands like the Toyo Open Country AT III.
• Winter Performance: Handles snow and icy conditions more effectively than typical all-terrain tires, such as the Sumitomo Encounter AT, but still falls short of dedicated winter tires.
• Comfort and Noise: While comfortable, it is slightly noisier than the Firestone Destination AT2, which could be a drawback for some users.
• Treadwear: Known for its durability and even wear, it offers significant long-term savings over less rugged options.

PROS

• Outstanding traction and stability in both wet and dry conditions.
• Very good performance in snow and ice for an all-terrain tire.
• Competitive pricing provides excellent value for the features offered.
• Durable construction designed for longevity, even under tough conditions.

CONS

• Higher road noise compared to more urban-focused all-terrain tires.
• Not a replacement for specialized winter tires in extreme cold and snowy conditions.

BOTTOM LINE

The Falken WildPeak AT3W is an excellent investment for drivers looking for a high-quality all-terrain tire that offers versatile capabilities across a variety of driving conditions. Its ability to handle rough terrains and moderate winter conditions makes it a top choice for those who frequently encounter diverse environments. While it may be noisier than some alternatives, the combination of durability, performance, and cost-efficiency makes it one of the best all-terrain tires for the money on the market today. Whether for daily use or occasional adventurous journeys, the WildPeak AT3W stands ready to deliver robust performance without compromising on value.

Methodology for Ranking the Tires

When it comes to choosing the best all-terrain tires for the money, it’s essential to consider a blend of performance, durability, and cost. The tires discussed in this article were ranked based on a comprehensive analysis that considers these key factors.

Here’s a closer look at the methodology used for ranking:

Performance Metrics Evaluation

Each tire was evaluated across a variety of performance metrics including traction in wet and dry conditions, handling in snow and ice, comfort, noise levels, and durability. The scores were gathered from controlled tests and consumer feedback to ensure a balanced view of each tire’s capabilities.

Cost Analysis

The price of each tire is a crucial factor, especially for budget-conscious buyers. Each tire’s cost was compared to its performance scores to determine the value for money it offers. This price-to-performance ratio helps in identifying which tires provide the best overall value without sacrificing quality.

Comparison and Contrast

Tires were compared against each other to highlight strengths and identify potential weaknesses. This comparison not only reflects individual tire capabilities but also how they stack up in the broader market, considering both cheaper and more expensive alternatives.

Consumer Reviews and Long-Term Reliability

Consumer reviews and reports on long-term reliability were also factored into the rankings. Tires that perform well initially but wear down quickly or fail to deliver consistent performance over time were ranked lower, despite their initial appeal.

Resources

Below are some links you may find helpful when learning about tires:

• Off-Road All-Terrain Tire Ratings Charts – Tire Rack
• Best All-Terrain Tires for Trucks and SUVs – Car And Driver

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right all-terrain tire is crucial for ensuring optimal performance in various driving conditions. This article has highlighted the top five tires that provide the best value for money, focusing on their strengths and limitations in handling different terrains, including wet, dry, and snowy conditions.

Whether you prioritize durability, comfort, or cost-efficiency, there is an option that fits your needs. Remember to consider the specific demands of your typical driving environment when selecting a tire, as this will greatly influence your satisfaction and the tire’s performance.

Good luck and happy motoring.