5 Best All Weather Tires For Ice And Snow

Imagine you’re gearing up for winter: the temperatures drop, and the forecast calls for snow. You think about your car’s ability to handle slick roads and ice. What you need are tires that won’t let you down in winter’s worst. How do you choose the best all-weather tires for ice and snow? Let’s dive into the essentials that make a tire stand out in winter conditions.

The best all-weather tires for ice and snow, ranked for their outstanding performance, are:

1. Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive – Best in Heavy Snow & Ice
2. Michelin CrossClimate2 – Best in Light Snow
3. Bridgestone WeatherPeak
4. Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady
5. General AltiMAX 365 AW

In this article, you will find detailed reviews of each tire’s performance in wet, dry, and winter conditions, helping you understand which tire might be the best fit for your winter driving needs.

Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

The Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive stands out as a premier choice in the all-weather tire segment, designed for drivers seeking exceptional year-round performance. It is particularly well-suited for sedans and crossovers that require dependable operation across various climates, from wet spring roads to snowy winter lanes.

Performance Highlights: In wet conditions, this tire excels with superior hydroplaning resistance and wet traction, ensuring robust control and safety during heavy rainfalls. Its dry weather capabilities are equally impressive, providing excellent corner stability and dry traction along with a responsive steering feel, making it a top pick for those who appreciate spirited driving.

Winter conditions reveal the true strength of the Cinturato WeatherActive. It provides outstanding grip in light and heavy snow, nearly matching specialized winter tires in performance—a rare feat for an all-season tire. While its ice traction is very good, it slightly lags behind the top winter tires, but still comfortably outperforms many competitors in its category.

Comfort and Durability: Ride comfort is another significant advantage, with high scores in reducing road noise and smoothing out road imperfections, ensuring a pleasant drive. The tire’s durability is reflected in its excellent treadwear rating, suggesting a long lifespan and maintaining performance integrity over time.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Sets the standard in its class for handling and safety in wet conditions.
• Dry Performance: Among the best, providing secure and enjoyable driving dynamics.
• Winter Performance: Exceptional in snow; very good on ice, though not quite reaching the pinnacle set by dedicated ice tires.
• Comfort and Noise: Offers one of the most comfortable rides, with minimal noise at high speeds.
• Treadwear: Superior longevity that promises extended usability without performance degradation.

PROS

• Outstanding traction and stability in both wet and dry conditions.
• Excellent snow handling capabilities, rivaling dedicated winter tires.
• Superior comfort and a quiet ride enhance the driving experience.
• Durable tread design extends tire life and value over time.

CONS

• Ice grip, while strong, does not lead the segment and might fall short under extreme winter conditions.
• Premium performance comes at a higher price point, which may not fit all budgets.

BOTTOMLINE

The Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive is a top-tier all-weather tire that offers a near-perfect blend of features for drivers who demand the best in performance, comfort, and durability. It excels in nearly every weather condition, with particular prowess in handling snow-covered roads. While it commands a premium, its comprehensive capabilities justify the investment, making it a standout choice for discerning motorists. This tire not only meets but often exceeds expectations, firmly positioning it as a leader in the all-weather category. For those looking to navigate diverse climates without changing tires seasonally, the Cinturato WeatherActive offers a compelling mix of safety, longevity, and peak performance.

Michelin CrossClimate 2

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

The Michelin CrossClimate2 is a highly regarded all-weather tire that provides exceptional versatility and robust performance across varied driving conditions. It is well-suited for drivers of sedans, SUVs, and crossovers who face changing weather patterns and require a reliable tire for both daily commuting and occasional adventurous drives.

Performance Highlights: In wet conditions, the CrossClimate2 offers excellent hydroplaning resistance and wet traction, comparable to the best in its class, ensuring driver confidence during rainy drives. Its dry weather performance is also top-notch with commendable corner stability, dry traction, and a precise steering response that appeals to those who enjoy an engaging driving experience.

The tire particularly shines in winter conditions with its superior ability to handle light and heavy snow. While its ice traction is robust and better than many all-season tires, it still does not match the absolute grip provided by specialized winter tires, which may be a consideration for those in particularly icy regions.

Comfort and Durability: Michelin’s focus on comfort is evident, as the CrossClimate2 scores highly on ride smoothness and noise reduction, making long drives more pleasant. The durability of this tire is also a highlight, with its treadwear indicating less frequent need for replacement and consistent performance year after year.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Rivals the best for safety and control in wet conditions.
• Dry Performance: Excels with secure traction and responsiveness, enhancing driver satisfaction.
• Winter Performance: Outstanding in snow capabilities; very good on ice, though not the best available.
• Comfort and Noise: Among the leaders in providing a smooth and quiet ride.
• Treadwear: Excellent durability which supports prolonged usage without compromise.

PROS

• Superior wet and dry handling, ensuring safety and driver engagement.
• Excellent snow and very good ice performance, suitable for all but the most severe winter conditions.
• High comfort levels with significant noise reduction for a more enjoyable ride.
• Impressive durability that promises long-term savings and reliability.

CONS

• While ice traction is very good, it does not top the category, potentially limiting it in extreme icy conditions.
• Premium pricing may deter some buyers looking for budget-friendly options.

BOTTOMLINE

The Michelin CrossClimate2 is a formidable choice in the all-weather tire market, offering a blend of safety, performance, and durability that is hard to beat. It performs admirably across all weather conditions, with a slight caveat in ice traction where it is very good but not the best. This makes it a perfect option for those who rarely face extreme winter conditions but still require a tire that can confidently handle the occasional snow and ice. Its combination of comfort, lasting tread life, and overall driving pleasure ensures that the CrossClimate2 is not just a purchase, but an investment in year-round driving confidence. For drivers looking for a tire that nearly does it all, the Michelin CrossClimate2 stands very close to the top, edged out slightly by the Pirelli in terms of ultimate snow and ice performance.

Bridgestone WeatherPeak

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

The Bridgestone WeatherPeak is a reliable all-weather tire that offers solid performance for drivers who face a variety of environmental conditions. This tire is ideal for those driving sedans, minivans, and smaller SUVs who value safety and stability across changing weather patterns, particularly in regions that experience moderate winter conditions.

Performance Highlights: The WeatherPeak excels in wet conditions with very good hydroplaning resistance and wet traction that provide safe and controlled handling during rainy periods. In dry conditions, it maintains a high level of performance with good corner stability and excellent traction, supported by a responsive steering that enhances the driving experience.

In winter scenarios, the WeatherPeak performs well with competent handling in both light and heavy snow. Its ice traction is decent but does not reach the top of its class, making it more suitable for areas with occasional ice rather than severe icy conditions.

Comfort and Durability: Bridgestone has engineered the WeatherPeak to offer a comfortable ride, minimizing road noise and smoothing out road irregularities, which contributes to a pleasant driving experience in all seasons. The tire’s treadwear is also a strong point, indicating durability and the potential for long-term usage without performance drop-off.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Strong in its category, providing reliable control in wet conditions.
• Dry Performance: Offers solid dry weather capabilities, though slightly behind the very best in responsiveness.
• Winter Performance: Good performance in snow; ice traction is adequate but not optimal for harsh winter environments.
• Comfort and Noise: Scores well, ensuring comfort that competes closely with higher-end models.
• Treadwear: Excellent durability, aligning it with the best for long-lasting service.

PROS

• Robust wet and dry traction ensures safe and enjoyable driving.
• Effective snow handling makes it a reliable option for winter.
• Comfortable and quiet, which enhances overall vehicle enjoyment.
• Durable design promotes a longer lifespan and sustained performance.

CONS

• Ice performance is competent but falls short compared to leaders like Pirelli and Michelin, which may be a critical factor for those in colder climates.
• Dry responsiveness is good but not the peak, potentially affecting those who prioritize driving dynamics.

BOTTOMLINE

The Bridgestone WeatherPeak is a strong contender in the all-weather tire market, providing a well-rounded profile that makes it a viable option for a wide range of drivers. It offers dependable performance in both wet and snowy conditions, with a slight compromise in ice handling that should be considered by those in colder regions. The tire’s comfort and durability are significant benefits that underscore its value, making it a sensible choice for individuals looking for reliable, year-round usability without the need for specialized winter tires. While it may not top the charts in every performance category, its overall balance of features positions it as a solid, versatile tire suited for diverse driving needs.

Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

The Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady is engineered as a comprehensive all-weather tire suitable for drivers who prioritize safety and reliability across various weather conditions. It is particularly fitting for family sedans, crossovers, and small SUVs. This tire integrates advanced technologies to deliver consistent performance whether navigating wet highways or snow-covered back roads.

Performance Highlights: In wet conditions, the Assurance WeatherReady demonstrates excellent hydroplaning resistance and wet traction, making it one of the safest choices in heavy rain. Dry conditions are handled with aplomb, featuring good corner stability, robust dry traction, and a responsive steering feel that contributes positively to driving confidence.

Where the Assurance WeatherReady truly aims to shine is in its winter performance; it manages light snow with ease and provides reasonable handling in heavier snow. However, its ice performance, while adequate, doesn’t match the capabilities of the top performers in the segment, particularly in very cold conditions.

Comfort and Durability: Goodyear has not compromised on comfort, with the Assurance WeatherReady offering a ride that competes well in terms of smoothness and noise reduction against other premium all-weather tires. The durability of this tire is commendable, evidenced by good treadwear ratings that suggest it can withstand multiple seasons without significant wear.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Excellent, ensuring top-tier handling and safety in rainy conditions.
• Dry Performance: Strong, though not the absolute best in class for steering responsiveness.
• Winter Performance: Capable in light to moderate snow but falls short in ice performance compared to the Pirelli and Michelin.
• Comfort and Noise: Provides a comfortable, quiet ride, nearly on par with the best in its category.
• Treadwear: Durable, indicating a long life and consistent performance over time.

PROS

• Superior wet traction and hydroplaning resistance offer peace of mind during rainy drives.
• Dependable performance in light and moderate snow conditions.
• High levels of comfort and reduced noise enhance the driving experience.
• Long-lasting durability ensures good value over the tire’s lifespan.

CONS

• Ice traction is sufficient for occasional icy conditions but may not be reliable in extreme winter climates.
• While dry performance is strong, it lacks the peak responsiveness seen in some competitors, which might be noticed by more spirited drivers.

BOTTOMLINE

The Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady is an adept all-weather tire that addresses a broad spectrum of weather conditions effectively, making it a solid choice for everyday driving. It excels in wet conditions and offers a comfortable ride, paired with the promise of longevity. Its performance in snow and ice, while generally competent, does not lead the pack, particularly when compared to specialized winter tires or the very best all-weather options like the Pirelli and Michelin. This tire is ideal for drivers who encounter diverse but not extreme winter conditions, providing a reliable compromise between performance and cost. For those looking for a tire that performs well across most scenarios without breaking the bank, the Assurance WeatherReady is a compelling option.

General AltiMAX 365 AW

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics

---

---

The General AltiMAX 365 AW is tailored for drivers seeking a dependable all-weather tire that performs adequately across diverse climatic conditions. It is particularly well-suited for compact cars, sedans, and small SUVs, offering a balanced approach to handling wet, dry, and snowy roads without the premium price tag of some competitors.

Performance Highlights: The AltiMAX 365 AW provides good hydroplaning resistance and wet traction, which ensures stability and control during rainy drives, though it does not top the charts in this category. Its dry performance is respectable, featuring solid corner stability and sufficient traction, but the steering response may not satisfy drivers who prefer a more dynamic driving feel.

Winter performance is where the AltiMAX 365 AW meets the needs of those in milder winter regions. It handles light snow adequately but struggles with ice and heavier snow accumulations, which could be a limitation for those in harsher winter climates.

Comfort and Durability: General has engineered the AltiMAX 365 AW to offer a comfortable and quiet ride, which is a standout feature at its price point. The tire’s durability is also a highlight, with a treadwear rating that promises longevity, although it may not reach the lifespan of higher-end models.

COMPARISON WITH LEADING COMPETITORS

• Wet Performance: Good capability in wet conditions, though it falls slightly behind the leaders like Michelin and Pirelli.
• Dry Performance: Sufficient for everyday driving needs but lacks the responsiveness and traction of top-tier tires.
• Winter Performance: Adequate for light snow but not the best choice for areas with frequent heavy snow or ice.
• Comfort and Noise: Very good, providing a ride that is more comfortable than many at this price level.
• Treadwear: Promises durability, but longevity may be slightly less than what you would get from premium competitors.

PROS

• Consistent and reliable performance in wet conditions.
• Suitable for light snow, fitting for drivers in regions with moderate winter weather.
• Provides a notably comfortable and quiet driving experience.
• Offers good durability and tread life at a competitive price point.

CONS

• Ice and heavy snow performance is mediocre, necessitating caution or an alternative tire in severe winter conditions.
• Dry handling and responsiveness are not as sharp as higher-priced alternatives, which might be noticeable to enthusiastic drivers.

BOTTOMLINE

The General AltiMAX 365 AW is a solid all-weather option for budget-conscious drivers who need a tire capable of handling a variety of weather conditions moderately well. It stands out for its comfort and cost-effectiveness but does not excel in severe winter scenarios or offer the best dynamic driving experience. This tire is ideal for those who face mild to moderate conditions and want a reliable, no-frills tire that delivers consistent performance where it counts. While it doesn’t match the top performance of more expensive tires like the Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive or Michelin CrossClimate2, it provides a viable compromise between capability and affordability for everyday driving.

All-Weather Tires vs Snow Tires

When preparing for winter driving, choosing the right type of tire is crucial for ensuring safety and performance. All-weather tires and snow tires are two popular options, each with its own set of advantages and drawbacks. Understanding these can help you make an informed decision based on your specific driving conditions and needs.

All-Weather Tires

Pros

• Versatility: All-weather tires are designed to handle a variety of road conditions effectively, from dry asphalt and rainy roads to light snow and slush. This makes them a practical year-round option, eliminating the need for seasonal tire changes.
• Economic Efficiency: Investing in one set of tires rather than purchasing both summer and winter sets can be more cost-effective. All-weather tires also tend to wear down more slowly than snow tires, which are made from softer compounds.
• Moderate Winter Performance: Many all-weather tires come with the 3-Peak Mountain Snowflake certification, which means they are tested to perform adequately in moderate winter conditions.

Cons

• Compromise on Extreme Performance: While all-weather tires perform well in various conditions, they do not excel in extreme weather like heavy snow and ice as much as dedicated snow tires.
• Less Effective on Ice: The compound and tread design of all-weather tires are a compromise, which generally makes them less effective on ice compared to snow tires.

Snow Tires

Pros

• Superior Winter Traction: Snow tires are specifically engineered for cold temperatures and winter precipitation. Their tread design allows them to bite into snow and ice, providing superior traction compared to all-weather tires.
• Better Braking Performance: In winter conditions, snow tires significantly reduce stopping distances thanks to their soft rubber compounds and high-density siping (thin slits in the tread).
• Optimized for Cold Weather: Snow tires are made from a softer rubber compound that remains flexible in freezing temperatures, enhancing grip and handling when it’s most needed.

Cons

• Seasonal Change Required: Snow tires should not be used year-round. The softer rubber compound that provides excellent grip in cold weather wears down quickly in warmer conditions, requiring a change back to summer or all-weather tires as seasons change.
• Increased Road Noise and Less Comfort: Snow tires can be noisier and offer a less smooth ride compared to all-weather tires because of their aggressive tread patterns.
• Cost Implications: Purchasing and maintaining two sets of tires, including storage for the off-season set, adds additional costs.

Making the Right Choice

The decision between all-weather and snow tires ultimately depends on your typical driving conditions and how much winter weather you expect to encounter. If you live in an area with mild winters, all-weather tires might be sufficient. However, for regions with severe winter conditions, snow tires are indispensable for maintaining safety and performance. Always consider how each option aligns with your needs to ensure the best driving experience throughout the year.

Resources

Below are some links you may find helpful when learning about tires:

• Winter tire safety tips – NHTSA
• All-weather tires vs. winter tires: What’s the difference? – Firestone

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right all-weather tire for ice and snow is crucial for safe winter driving. The Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive and Michelin CrossClimate2 stand out as the top performers, with Pirelli excelling in heavy snow conditions and Michelin shining in lighter snowfalls. The Bridgestone WeatherPeak and Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady offer reliable alternatives that balance performance across various conditions, whereas the General AltiMAX 365 AW provides the best ice performance, suitable for milder winter climates.

Each tire reviewed offers a blend of benefits for wet, dry, and snowy conditions, with specific strengths that could make them the ideal choice depending on your regional climate and driving habits. Remember to consider not only the tire’s capabilities but also factors like noise level, comfort, and treadwear, which can greatly influence your driving experience.

Good luck and happy motoring.