Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Vs Toyo Proxes ST III

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Vs Toyo Proxes ST III


 | 

Time To Read:

11 minutes

 | 

Time To Read:

11 minutes

Considering the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus or the Toyo Proxes ST III for your high-performance SUV or light truck but unsure which is the better fit? You’re in the right place. With so many tire options out there, picking the right one can feel like trying to choose the best dish at a gourmet restaurant. This comparison will give you the clear, straightforward facts to help you decide.

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus excels in wet and winter conditions, offering superior comfort and reduced noise, while the Toyo Proxes ST III stands out in dry performance with a stylish design and durable tread.

In this article, we’ll compare the key features, performance metrics, and real-world feedback of both the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus and the Toyo Proxes ST III. You’ll discover how they stack up against top competitors and determine which tire suits your driving needs best.

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus

Customer Rating

Overall Rating

8.4 of 10

Wet Weather

8.7 of 10

Winter Weather

7.3 of 10

Tread Wear

8.2 of 10

Dry Weather

9.1 of 10

Ride Comfort

8.7 of 10

UTQG

Uniform Tire Quality Grade

UTQG Treadwear Rating: 500

UTQG Traction Rating: A

UTQG Temperature Rating: A

Mileage Warranty

6 Years / 50,000 Miles

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics


Hydroplaning: 8.6 of 10

Wet Grip: 8.8 of 10


Cornering: 9.0 of 10

Dry Grip: 9.1 of 10

Responsiveness: 9.0 of 10

Mild Snow Grip: 7.3 of 10

Heavy Snow Grip: 7.9 of 10

Ice Grip: 7.3 of 10


Comfort Level: 8.8 of 10

Road Noise: 8.6 of 10

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus is engineered for drivers seeking a tire that offers a blend of performance and style. This all-season tire is specifically designed for high-performance SUVs and light trucks, delivering excellent handling and a smooth, quiet ride. Whether you’re cruising on the highway or taking a spirited drive on winding roads, the Scorpion Zero All Season Plus ensures stability and confidence in various conditions.

Key Features

  • High-Performance All-Season Traction: With an advanced tread design and unique compound, the Scorpion Zero All Season Plus provides reliable traction on wet, dry, and light snowy roads. The tire’s optimized sipes and grooves enhance grip and stability, making it a versatile choice for year-round driving.
  • Comfort and Quiet Ride: The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus features Pirelli’s Noise Cancelling System, which reduces road noise for a quieter ride. Its tread pattern is designed to minimize vibrations, ensuring a comfortable driving experience even on long journeys.
  • Enhanced Handling and Stability: Constructed with a robust carcass and high-density rubber compound, this tire is built to handle high speeds and sharp turns. The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus delivers precise steering response and cornering stability.
  • Stylish Design: The tire’s sporty appearance complements high-performance vehicles, adding a touch of style to your ride.

Performance Breakdown

Wet Performance (8.7)

  • Hydroplaning Resistance: 8.6
  • Wet Traction: 8.8

The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus performs admirably in wet conditions. With hydroplaning resistance at 8.6 and wet traction at 8.8, these tires keep you steady even when the roads are slick. It’s like having rain boots with excellent grip – you stay secure and confident.

Dry Performance (9.1)

  • Corner Stability: 9.0
  • Dry Traction: 9.1
  • Steering Response: 9.0

On dry roads, the Scorpion Zero All Season Plus shines. With corner stability and steering response both rated highly, driving feels safe and controlled. Imagine driving a finely-tuned vehicle that responds smoothly to every turn – it’s both reassuring and enjoyable.

Winter/Snow Performance (7.3)

  • Light Snow Traction: 7.9
  • Deep Snow Traction: 7.3
  • Ice Traction: 6.8

The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus handles light snow quite well but struggles a bit more with deep snow and ice. Think of it as wearing decent winter shoes – they get the job done for moderate conditions but aren’t the best for extreme winter weather.

Comfort (8.7)

  • Ride Quality: 8.8
  • Noise: 8.6

This tire provides a comfortable ride with reduced noise levels. It’s designed to smooth out the bumps and keep things quiet, making your drive more pleasant. It’s like riding in a car equipped with noise-cancelling technology – peaceful and smooth.

Treadwear (8.2)

The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus is built to last. With a treadwear rating of 8.2, you can expect these tires to go the distance, offering good value over time.

Pros

  • Excellent dry performance with great corner stability and steering response
  • Very good wet traction and hydroplaning resistance
  • Comfortable ride with minimal noise
  • Stylish design that enhances vehicle appearance

Cons

  • Average performance in deep snow and on ice
  • Treadwear could be better compared to some competitors

Toyo Proxes ST III

Customer Rating

Overall Rating

8.1 of 10

Wet Weather

8.3 of 10

Winter Weather

6.4 of 10

Tread Wear

8.3 of 10

Dry Weather

9.1 of 10

Ride Comfort

8.3 of 10

UTQG

Uniform Tire Quality Grade

UTQG Treadwear Rating: 500

UTQG Traction Rating: A

UTQG Temperature Rating: A

Mileage Warranty

5 Years / 40,000 Miles

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics


Hydroplaning: 8.3 of 10

Wet Grip: 8.3 of 10


Cornering: 9.1 of 10

Dry Grip: 9.2 of 10

Responsiveness: 9.1 of 10

Mild Snow Grip: 7.1 of 10

Heavy Snow Grip: 6.4 of 10

Ice Grip: 5.8 of 10


Comfort Level: 8.5 of 10

Road Noise: 8.1 of 10

The Toyo Proxes ST III is designed for drivers who crave performance and style in their street/sport trucks. This all-season tire is specifically engineered for high-performance SUVs and light trucks, offering excellent handling and a sporty look. Whether you’re navigating city streets or hitting the open road, the Proxes ST III provides a stable and confident ride in various conditions.

Key Features

  • High-Performance All-Season Traction: The Proxes ST III features an advanced tread design and special rubber compound to provide dependable traction on wet, dry, and light snowy roads. The tire’s wide tread grooves and multiple sipes improve grip and stability, making it a versatile option for all-season driving.
  • Sporty and Stylish Design: With its aggressive tread pattern and sleek sidewall design, the Proxes ST III adds a sporty aesthetic to your vehicle, enhancing its overall look.
  • Enhanced Handling and Stability: The Proxes ST III is built with a sturdy carcass and a high-grip compound to handle high speeds and sharp turns. This tire offers precise steering response and excellent cornering stability.
  • Comfort and Reduced Noise: The tire’s optimized tread pattern helps reduce road noise, providing a quieter and more comfortable ride.
  • Durability and Long Tread Life: The Proxes ST III is designed for longevity, offering a durable construction that ensures a longer tread life.

Performance Breakdown

Wet Performance (8.3)

  • Hydroplaning Resistance: 8.3
  • Wet Traction: 8.3

The Proxes ST III handles wet conditions fairly well. With hydroplaning resistance and wet traction both at 8.3, these tires provide adequate performance on rainy days. It’s like having a decent pair of rain boots – they keep you secure but aren’t the best in a downpour.

Dry Performance (9.1)

  • Corner Stability: 9.1
  • Dry Traction: 9.2
  • Steering Response: 9.1

In dry conditions, the Proxes ST III excels. With high ratings in corner stability, dry traction, and steering response, driving feels precise and controlled. Picture driving a sports car that hugs the road – it’s exhilarating and reassuring.

Winter/Snow Performance (6.4)

  • Light Snow Traction: 7.1
  • Deep Snow Traction: 6.3
  • Ice Traction: 5.7

The Proxes ST III struggles in winter conditions, particularly in deep snow and ice. It’s akin to wearing thin gloves in the cold – they work in a pinch but aren’t ideal for harsh winter weather.

Comfort (8.3)

  • Ride Quality: 8.5
  • Noise: 8.1

This tire offers a comfortable ride with a focus on reducing noise. It’s designed to smooth out your drive, making it more pleasant. Think of it as riding in a car with a good sound system – enjoyable and relaxing.

Treadwear (8.3)

The Proxes ST III is built to last, with a treadwear rating of 8.3. You can expect these tires to provide good value and longevity.

Pros

  • Excellent dry performance with great corner stability and steering response
  • Stylish and sporty design
  • Comfortable ride with reduced noise
  • Good tread life for extended use

Cons

  • Average wet performance compared to top competitors
  • Struggles in deep snow and ice conditions
  • Comfort could be better compared to some other high-performance tires
Hydroplaning Resistance And Wet Traction Are Critical For Safety.
Hydroplaning Resistance And Wet Traction Are Critical For Safety.

Comparative Analysis

When choosing the right tire for your street/sport truck, the details matter. Both the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus and the Toyo Proxes ST III offer unique features for the discerning driver, but their strengths cater to slightly different driving preferences and priorities. Let’s break it down to help you decide which tire might be the best fit for your ride.

Performance in Wet Conditions

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Hydroplaning Resistance 8.6 8.3
Wet Traction 8.8 8.3

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus leads in wet conditions with higher scores in hydroplaning resistance and wet traction. This makes it more suitable for those who frequently drive in rainy conditions, providing better safety and control on wet roads.

Dry Performance

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Corner Stability 9.0 9.1
Dry Traction 9.1 9.2
Steering Response 9.0 9.1

Both tires excel in dry conditions, but the Toyo Proxes ST III has a slight edge with slightly higher scores in corner stability, dry traction, and steering response. If you enjoy spirited driving and need a tire that offers precise handling, the Toyo Proxes ST III might be the better choice.

Winter/Snow Performance

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Light Snow Traction 7.9 7.1
Deep Snow Traction 7.3 6.3
Ice Traction 6.8 5.7

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus performs better in winter conditions, with higher scores in light and deep snow traction, as well as ice traction. If you live in an area with occasional snow and icy conditions, the Pirelli offers better reliability in winter weather.

Comfort and Noise

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Ride Quality 8.8 8.5
Noise 8.6 8.1

On the comfort front, the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus provides a slightly better ride quality and reduced noise levels. If you spend a lot of time driving and value a quiet, comfortable ride, the Pirelli has the upper hand.

Treadwear and Durability

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Treadwear 8.2 8.3

The Toyo Proxes ST III slightly outperforms the Pirelli in treadwear, making it a durable choice for those looking for long-lasting tires. If you’re planning on keeping your tires for a long period and want good value for your investment, the Toyo Proxes ST III might be the better option.

The Verdict

  • Choose Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus if: You prioritize top-notch performance in wet and winter conditions, and comfort and noise levels are crucial for your regular driving experience. This tire is ideal for drivers in varied climates or those who prefer a quieter ride.
  • Opt for Toyo Proxes ST III if: You’re looking for excellent dry performance and a stylish design at a potentially lower price point. This tire suits drivers who enjoy spirited driving and need a durable option for long-term use.
All Season/Weather Tires Are Not A Replacement For Proper Winter Tires.
All Season/Weather Tires Are Not A Replacement For Proper Winter Tires.

Other Competitors in the Market

While the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus and the Toyo Proxes ST III hold their ground as top contenders, the tire market is bustling with alternatives that might better align with specific needs or budgets. Let’s explore a few other players in the Street/Sport Truck All-Season Tire category and see how they stack up.

Yokohama Parada Spec-X

Yokohama Parada Spec-X
Yokohama Parada Spec-X

Performance Ratings:

  • Wet: 8.7
  • Dry: 9.0
  • Winter/Snow: 7.2
  • Comfort: 8.7
  • Treadwear: 7.9

Pros: Excellent dry performance with good wet traction and comfort.

Cons: Struggles in deep snow and ice conditions.

Ideal Usage: Suitable for drivers in mild climates who prioritize dry handling and ride comfort.

Hankook Ventus ST RH06

Hankook Ventus ST RH06
Hankook Ventus ST RH06

Performance Ratings:

  • Wet: 8.5
  • Dry: 9.2
  • Winter/Snow: 6.4
  • Comfort: 8.7
  • Treadwear: 8.6

Pros: Exceptional dry performance with long tread life.

Cons: Poor performance in winter conditions, especially on ice.

Ideal Usage: Best for drivers in warmer climates who prioritize dry traction and longevity.

Goodyear Fortera SL Edition

Goodyear Fortera SL Edition
Goodyear Fortera SL Edition

Performance Ratings:

  • Wet: 8.0
  • Dry: 8.8
  • Winter/Snow: 6.2
  • Comfort: 8.3
  • Treadwear: 7.9

Pros: Reasonable performance at an affordable price point.

Cons: The lowest ratings in winter performance, especially on ice, and moderate treadwear.

Ideal Usage: Suited for budget-conscious drivers who primarily drive in dry conditions and can manage more frequent tire replacements.

Each of these alternatives offers a unique set of features that cater to different driving styles and priorities:

  • For Balanced Value and Performance: The Yokohama Parada Spec-X strikes a good balance, offering solid performance without the premium price tag. It’s ideal for those who drive in varying conditions but don’t want to splurge on the top-tier options.
  • For Durability and Dry Performance: The Hankook Ventus ST RH06 shines in providing long tread life and exceptional dry traction, making it perfect for high-mileage drivers in warmer climates.
  • For Budget-Friendly Options: The Goodyear Fortera SL Edition presents a viable option for those who need to adhere to stricter budgets. While it doesn’t offer the best performance metrics, it maintains a respectable level of quality for its price range.

Resources

Below are some links you may find helpful when learning about tires:

Final Thoughts

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus impresses with its excellent wet performance, comfort, and noise reduction, making it a top choice for those who drive in varied weather conditions. It also offers decent winter capabilities, though it slightly trails in dry traction and treadwear compared to its peers.

The Toyo Proxes ST III shines in dry performance, with superior corner stability and steering response, and it boasts a stylish design. However, it falls short in wet and winter conditions, and while it offers good treadwear, its comfort and noise levels are not as high as some competitors.

Overall, the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus is on par with the leaders in wet and winter performance but slightly behind in dry conditions and treadwear. The Toyo Proxes ST III is a strong contender for those prioritizing dry performance and durability over all-season versatility.

Good luck and happy motoring.

About The Author

Considering the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus or the Toyo Proxes ST III for your high-performance SUV or light truck but unsure which is the better fit? You’re in the right place. With so many tire options out there, picking the right one can feel like trying to choose the best dish at a gourmet restaurant. This comparison will give you the clear, straightforward facts to help you decide.

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus excels in wet and winter conditions, offering superior comfort and reduced noise, while the Toyo Proxes ST III stands out in dry performance with a stylish design and durable tread.

In this article, we’ll compare the key features, performance metrics, and real-world feedback of both the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus and the Toyo Proxes ST III. You’ll discover how they stack up against top competitors and determine which tire suits your driving needs best.

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus

Customer Rating

Overall Rating

8.4 of 10

Wet Weather

8.7 of 10

Winter Weather

7.3 of 10

Tread Wear

8.2 of 10

Dry Weather

9.1 of 10

Ride Comfort

8.7 of 10

UTQG

Uniform Tire Quality Grade

UTQG Treadwear Rating: 500

UTQG Traction Rating: A

UTQG Temperature Rating: A

Mileage Warranty

6 Years / 50,000 Miles

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics


Hydroplaning: 8.6 of 10

Wet Grip: 8.8 of 10


Cornering: 9.0 of 10

Dry Grip: 9.1 of 10

Responsiveness: 9.0 of 10

Mild Snow Grip: 7.3 of 10

Heavy Snow Grip: 7.9 of 10

Ice Grip: 7.3 of 10


Comfort Level: 8.8 of 10

Road Noise: 8.6 of 10

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus is engineered for drivers seeking a tire that offers a blend of performance and style. This all-season tire is specifically designed for high-performance SUVs and light trucks, delivering excellent handling and a smooth, quiet ride. Whether you’re cruising on the highway or taking a spirited drive on winding roads, the Scorpion Zero All Season Plus ensures stability and confidence in various conditions.

Key Features

  • High-Performance All-Season Traction: With an advanced tread design and unique compound, the Scorpion Zero All Season Plus provides reliable traction on wet, dry, and light snowy roads. The tire’s optimized sipes and grooves enhance grip and stability, making it a versatile choice for year-round driving.
  • Comfort and Quiet Ride: The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus features Pirelli’s Noise Cancelling System, which reduces road noise for a quieter ride. Its tread pattern is designed to minimize vibrations, ensuring a comfortable driving experience even on long journeys.
  • Enhanced Handling and Stability: Constructed with a robust carcass and high-density rubber compound, this tire is built to handle high speeds and sharp turns. The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus delivers precise steering response and cornering stability.
  • Stylish Design: The tire’s sporty appearance complements high-performance vehicles, adding a touch of style to your ride.

Performance Breakdown

Wet Performance (8.7)

  • Hydroplaning Resistance: 8.6
  • Wet Traction: 8.8

The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus performs admirably in wet conditions. With hydroplaning resistance at 8.6 and wet traction at 8.8, these tires keep you steady even when the roads are slick. It’s like having rain boots with excellent grip – you stay secure and confident.

Dry Performance (9.1)

  • Corner Stability: 9.0
  • Dry Traction: 9.1
  • Steering Response: 9.0

On dry roads, the Scorpion Zero All Season Plus shines. With corner stability and steering response both rated highly, driving feels safe and controlled. Imagine driving a finely-tuned vehicle that responds smoothly to every turn – it’s both reassuring and enjoyable.

Winter/Snow Performance (7.3)

  • Light Snow Traction: 7.9
  • Deep Snow Traction: 7.3
  • Ice Traction: 6.8

The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus handles light snow quite well but struggles a bit more with deep snow and ice. Think of it as wearing decent winter shoes – they get the job done for moderate conditions but aren’t the best for extreme winter weather.

Comfort (8.7)

  • Ride Quality: 8.8
  • Noise: 8.6

This tire provides a comfortable ride with reduced noise levels. It’s designed to smooth out the bumps and keep things quiet, making your drive more pleasant. It’s like riding in a car equipped with noise-cancelling technology – peaceful and smooth.

Treadwear (8.2)

The Scorpion Zero All Season Plus is built to last. With a treadwear rating of 8.2, you can expect these tires to go the distance, offering good value over time.

Pros

  • Excellent dry performance with great corner stability and steering response
  • Very good wet traction and hydroplaning resistance
  • Comfortable ride with minimal noise
  • Stylish design that enhances vehicle appearance

Cons

  • Average performance in deep snow and on ice
  • Treadwear could be better compared to some competitors

Toyo Proxes ST III

Customer Rating

Overall Rating

8.1 of 10

Wet Weather

8.3 of 10

Winter Weather

6.4 of 10

Tread Wear

8.3 of 10

Dry Weather

9.1 of 10

Ride Comfort

8.3 of 10

UTQG

Uniform Tire Quality Grade

UTQG Treadwear Rating: 500

UTQG Traction Rating: A

UTQG Temperature Rating: A

Mileage Warranty

5 Years / 40,000 Miles

Find The Best Price

Key Performance Metrics


Hydroplaning: 8.3 of 10

Wet Grip: 8.3 of 10


Cornering: 9.1 of 10

Dry Grip: 9.2 of 10

Responsiveness: 9.1 of 10

Mild Snow Grip: 7.1 of 10

Heavy Snow Grip: 6.4 of 10

Ice Grip: 5.8 of 10


Comfort Level: 8.5 of 10

Road Noise: 8.1 of 10

The Toyo Proxes ST III is designed for drivers who crave performance and style in their street/sport trucks. This all-season tire is specifically engineered for high-performance SUVs and light trucks, offering excellent handling and a sporty look. Whether you’re navigating city streets or hitting the open road, the Proxes ST III provides a stable and confident ride in various conditions.

Key Features

  • High-Performance All-Season Traction: The Proxes ST III features an advanced tread design and special rubber compound to provide dependable traction on wet, dry, and light snowy roads. The tire’s wide tread grooves and multiple sipes improve grip and stability, making it a versatile option for all-season driving.
  • Sporty and Stylish Design: With its aggressive tread pattern and sleek sidewall design, the Proxes ST III adds a sporty aesthetic to your vehicle, enhancing its overall look.
  • Enhanced Handling and Stability: The Proxes ST III is built with a sturdy carcass and a high-grip compound to handle high speeds and sharp turns. This tire offers precise steering response and excellent cornering stability.
  • Comfort and Reduced Noise: The tire’s optimized tread pattern helps reduce road noise, providing a quieter and more comfortable ride.
  • Durability and Long Tread Life: The Proxes ST III is designed for longevity, offering a durable construction that ensures a longer tread life.

Performance Breakdown

Wet Performance (8.3)

  • Hydroplaning Resistance: 8.3
  • Wet Traction: 8.3

The Proxes ST III handles wet conditions fairly well. With hydroplaning resistance and wet traction both at 8.3, these tires provide adequate performance on rainy days. It’s like having a decent pair of rain boots – they keep you secure but aren’t the best in a downpour.

Dry Performance (9.1)

  • Corner Stability: 9.1
  • Dry Traction: 9.2
  • Steering Response: 9.1

In dry conditions, the Proxes ST III excels. With high ratings in corner stability, dry traction, and steering response, driving feels precise and controlled. Picture driving a sports car that hugs the road – it’s exhilarating and reassuring.

Winter/Snow Performance (6.4)

  • Light Snow Traction: 7.1
  • Deep Snow Traction: 6.3
  • Ice Traction: 5.7

The Proxes ST III struggles in winter conditions, particularly in deep snow and ice. It’s akin to wearing thin gloves in the cold – they work in a pinch but aren’t ideal for harsh winter weather.

Comfort (8.3)

  • Ride Quality: 8.5
  • Noise: 8.1

This tire offers a comfortable ride with a focus on reducing noise. It’s designed to smooth out your drive, making it more pleasant. Think of it as riding in a car with a good sound system – enjoyable and relaxing.

Treadwear (8.3)

The Proxes ST III is built to last, with a treadwear rating of 8.3. You can expect these tires to provide good value and longevity.

Pros

  • Excellent dry performance with great corner stability and steering response
  • Stylish and sporty design
  • Comfortable ride with reduced noise
  • Good tread life for extended use

Cons

  • Average wet performance compared to top competitors
  • Struggles in deep snow and ice conditions
  • Comfort could be better compared to some other high-performance tires
Hydroplaning Resistance And Wet Traction Are Critical For Safety.
Hydroplaning Resistance And Wet Traction Are Critical For Safety.

Comparative Analysis

When choosing the right tire for your street/sport truck, the details matter. Both the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus and the Toyo Proxes ST III offer unique features for the discerning driver, but their strengths cater to slightly different driving preferences and priorities. Let’s break it down to help you decide which tire might be the best fit for your ride.

Performance in Wet Conditions

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Hydroplaning Resistance 8.6 8.3
Wet Traction 8.8 8.3

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus leads in wet conditions with higher scores in hydroplaning resistance and wet traction. This makes it more suitable for those who frequently drive in rainy conditions, providing better safety and control on wet roads.

Dry Performance

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Corner Stability 9.0 9.1
Dry Traction 9.1 9.2
Steering Response 9.0 9.1

Both tires excel in dry conditions, but the Toyo Proxes ST III has a slight edge with slightly higher scores in corner stability, dry traction, and steering response. If you enjoy spirited driving and need a tire that offers precise handling, the Toyo Proxes ST III might be the better choice.

Winter/Snow Performance

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Light Snow Traction 7.9 7.1
Deep Snow Traction 7.3 6.3
Ice Traction 6.8 5.7

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus performs better in winter conditions, with higher scores in light and deep snow traction, as well as ice traction. If you live in an area with occasional snow and icy conditions, the Pirelli offers better reliability in winter weather.

Comfort and Noise

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Ride Quality 8.8 8.5
Noise 8.6 8.1

On the comfort front, the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus provides a slightly better ride quality and reduced noise levels. If you spend a lot of time driving and value a quiet, comfortable ride, the Pirelli has the upper hand.

Treadwear and Durability

Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus Toyo Proxes ST III
Treadwear 8.2 8.3

The Toyo Proxes ST III slightly outperforms the Pirelli in treadwear, making it a durable choice for those looking for long-lasting tires. If you’re planning on keeping your tires for a long period and want good value for your investment, the Toyo Proxes ST III might be the better option.

The Verdict

  • Choose Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus if: You prioritize top-notch performance in wet and winter conditions, and comfort and noise levels are crucial for your regular driving experience. This tire is ideal for drivers in varied climates or those who prefer a quieter ride.
  • Opt for Toyo Proxes ST III if: You’re looking for excellent dry performance and a stylish design at a potentially lower price point. This tire suits drivers who enjoy spirited driving and need a durable option for long-term use.
All Season/Weather Tires Are Not A Replacement For Proper Winter Tires.
All Season/Weather Tires Are Not A Replacement For Proper Winter Tires.

Other Competitors in the Market

While the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus and the Toyo Proxes ST III hold their ground as top contenders, the tire market is bustling with alternatives that might better align with specific needs or budgets. Let’s explore a few other players in the Street/Sport Truck All-Season Tire category and see how they stack up.

Yokohama Parada Spec-X

Yokohama Parada Spec-X
Yokohama Parada Spec-X

Performance Ratings:

  • Wet: 8.7
  • Dry: 9.0
  • Winter/Snow: 7.2
  • Comfort: 8.7
  • Treadwear: 7.9

Pros: Excellent dry performance with good wet traction and comfort.

Cons: Struggles in deep snow and ice conditions.

Ideal Usage: Suitable for drivers in mild climates who prioritize dry handling and ride comfort.

Hankook Ventus ST RH06

Hankook Ventus ST RH06
Hankook Ventus ST RH06

Performance Ratings:

  • Wet: 8.5
  • Dry: 9.2
  • Winter/Snow: 6.4
  • Comfort: 8.7
  • Treadwear: 8.6

Pros: Exceptional dry performance with long tread life.

Cons: Poor performance in winter conditions, especially on ice.

Ideal Usage: Best for drivers in warmer climates who prioritize dry traction and longevity.

Goodyear Fortera SL Edition

Goodyear Fortera SL Edition
Goodyear Fortera SL Edition

Performance Ratings:

  • Wet: 8.0
  • Dry: 8.8
  • Winter/Snow: 6.2
  • Comfort: 8.3
  • Treadwear: 7.9

Pros: Reasonable performance at an affordable price point.

Cons: The lowest ratings in winter performance, especially on ice, and moderate treadwear.

Ideal Usage: Suited for budget-conscious drivers who primarily drive in dry conditions and can manage more frequent tire replacements.

Each of these alternatives offers a unique set of features that cater to different driving styles and priorities:

  • For Balanced Value and Performance: The Yokohama Parada Spec-X strikes a good balance, offering solid performance without the premium price tag. It’s ideal for those who drive in varying conditions but don’t want to splurge on the top-tier options.
  • For Durability and Dry Performance: The Hankook Ventus ST RH06 shines in providing long tread life and exceptional dry traction, making it perfect for high-mileage drivers in warmer climates.
  • For Budget-Friendly Options: The Goodyear Fortera SL Edition presents a viable option for those who need to adhere to stricter budgets. While it doesn’t offer the best performance metrics, it maintains a respectable level of quality for its price range.

Resources

Below are some links you may find helpful when learning about tires:

Final Thoughts

The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus impresses with its excellent wet performance, comfort, and noise reduction, making it a top choice for those who drive in varied weather conditions. It also offers decent winter capabilities, though it slightly trails in dry traction and treadwear compared to its peers.

The Toyo Proxes ST III shines in dry performance, with superior corner stability and steering response, and it boasts a stylish design. However, it falls short in wet and winter conditions, and while it offers good treadwear, its comfort and noise levels are not as high as some competitors.

Overall, the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season Plus is on par with the leaders in wet and winter performance but slightly behind in dry conditions and treadwear. The Toyo Proxes ST III is a strong contender for those prioritizing dry performance and durability over all-season versatility.

Good luck and happy motoring.



About The Author